Model Review System
This is the scoring chart I use to mark each category of my reviews out of 10. The categories reviewed are (where applicable): Exterior, paint, tampo/decals, tyres and wheels, brakes, engine and interior. By using this system I aim to keep my reviews consistent and accurate as far as possible. It may be the case that as time moves on, models get better and collectors expectations are altered, but this system should at least be a good guide to what sort of quality and detail you can expect to get in a model.
Many thanks once again to those at DiecastXchange who took the time to put this system together for members' use. Take some time to check out the Diecastxchange site for friendly forums, great discussions and all you could want to know about the hobby.
The Guide
1. A model in this range has absolutely nothing of interest to it. This rare model is considered to be the worst of the worst.
2. A model deserving of this score would not satisfy any collector as it has absolutely no positives. It would be difficult, however, not impossible to find a worse model.
3. A model in this range and lower should not even be considered by collectors. It has very few positives, and the flaws far outweigh them.
4. A model deserving of this score doesn't have many positives and the few that it does have are well below the expectations of a collector.
5. A model in this range is mediocre at best. Obvious flaws overshadow the positives.
6. A model in this range reflects an average model. Its positives and flaws balance each other out making it an adequate model. Not the worst, but also not the best.
7. A model scoring in this range has more positives than it has flaws, however, the flaws should be made aware of.
8. A model that receives this score is flawless in so many ways that its relative drawbacks are not very important if at all. Improving upon this model will take a very strong effort.
9. This score is a reflection of a model that distinguishes itself as one of the best available on the market. Accuracy, detail and quality are all present. A model deserving of this score suffers from no meaningful drawbacks. Although it would be difficult to improve upon this model, it would not be impossible.
10. This rare score is reserved for a model that is perfect as it could be. The flawless design and construction exceeds collectors’ expectations. A model deserving of this score cannot be improved upon and is considered to be the best available to collectors.
